New Zealand “As risky as Pakistan” and “associated with political risk”


NZ is often referred to as the Wild West of Investment

“New Zealand as risky as Pakistan, says Newton’s Pidcock” on Dec 11 2013

An Asian income specialist calls time on the New Zealand government’s handling of a regulatory dispute with a telecoms company. source (emphasis ours)

Newton Asian Income Fund manager Jason Pidcock claims a regulatory dispute in New Zealand contributed to a 7.2% loss for the fund since the end of October, leading him to brand the country as ‘politically risky as Pakistan‘.

The £4.3 billion fund was down 7.2% versus a 3.6% fall by the index between the end of October and 3 December, with Pidcock crediting most of the losses to the fallout from a row over New Zealand’s installation of an ultra-fast national broadband network.

Citywire A-rated Pidcock owns two utilities in New Zealand, Meridian and Mighty River Power, as well as Z Energy and telcom firms Telecom New Zealand and Chorus, which all yield 6.3% or more.

Pidcock’s country weighting had been 5.3% but this has now fallen to 4.2% after a combination of market falls and some selective selling.

I have to associate New Zealand with political risk. There was an extraordinary event in November where the government reneged on a pricing agreement with telecom firm Chorus,’ he said…

“Political risk”

‘It was a failure of the New Zealand government and it has caused a lot of upset in the investment community. It is akin to reducing the coupon on a government bond.’

Pidcock admitted this event had made him reluctant to invest further there as well as reassess his attitudes to risk. He did say, however, that another key overweight, Australia, would be unaffected by events in its neighbour.

We will not invest any more money in New Zealand for the foreseeable future. We have to rank it [alongside] places like Pakistan in terms of political risk. This is a shame because it ought to be a developed and stable country.’

Yes, it ought to be.

Got a New Zealand investment story you’d like to share with us? We’d like to hear from you.

You may also like

Goodbye New Zealand – sloppy workers and investments challenge

“…My first job in New Zealand was ok, although I found the work culture strange. The people in management viewed me suspiciously because I knew a great deal more than they did. I understood that a certain subset of Kiwis has a visceral and irrational hatred towards Americans, so I tended to be discrete and quiet to avoid eliciting antipathy.

I found it odd that so many called in sick on a Friday or before a long weekend. Kiwis also tended to be very slack and sloppy workers. The managers at the company tended to be idiots whose sole virtue was that they had managed to outlast their peers in an excruciatingly stifling environment or were mates of other managers. It did not concern me too much because I simply needed an income whilst I found a business. However, I did focus on doing a good job because I knew the importance of creating and safeguarding a reputation for excellence.

Eventually, the company had an “Investments Challenge”. I worked in the investments field in the US before I bought my own company, so I thought it presented an opportunity to prove my talents and I thought that it could translate into moving to their investments team. Ultimately, I won and trounced the local “financial advisers”. In fact, they changed the competition’s rules half way through because I made their highly remunerated “financial advisers” look bad. I won the competition along with $100 gift card. Subsequently, I applied for a position as an “adviser” with that company, but I did not have the “right experience”. I also asked my team leader for the company to pay for training so that I could become an Authorised Financial Adviser, but she declined… more here

“Close Minded Kiwis Ruined NZ For Us”

Significant Increase In Fraud In New Zealand Over Last Six Months

Returning Kiwis’ Views About New Zealand

2 thoughts on “New Zealand “As risky as Pakistan” and “associated with political risk”

Comments are closed.